Bear squad. Halton police shot and killed wandering bruin in Burlington.
Spectator reporter Hilary Caton wrote a brief news story Tuesday detailing reports of a black bear in Milton. Story seemed incredulous. Bears normally don't live in these parts.
We posted the story on thespec.com and one of the comments submitted challenged the authenticity of the claim:
“Where are the pictures? Need some evidence otherwise this is just a Loch Ness...”
Today, the bear took a fatal jaunt south and made its way into Burlington. It’s a great place to visit, but not if you’re a bear. A police tactical team found the bear and shot it. Three times, maybe four.
The story is front page news – it’s not everyday a bear wanders into Burlington and then is shot. The story is news, it's unusual, it's a curiosity and it's a matter of public concern and safety. (an aside - a black bear was shot in Greensville, a Hamilton suburb, in July 2004. There was much controversy, not so much because of photos and video. We received letters debating the right to kill a bear and who should kill it. Some felt it should have been tranquilized.)
Now debate now over how to tell the story of Burlington's dead bruin. Is it offensive to show pictures of the dead bear? We have such photos and one of them is on the Spec's website. I don’t find it grisly or gruesome, but certainly some do and are offended. (Note: a small photo of the dead bear is at the end of this post).
Last week a young woman riding her horse collided with a truck. The woman and horse were killed. A freelance photographer arrived at the scene and captured a dramatic scene showing the dead horse. The photo gave context to the accident surroundings (photo is also below). Some people found the photo offensive.
This is reminiscent of a similar story in January when sharpshooters in Halton picked off an ornery coyote that bit a little girl. That post, What if this were a pitbull raised that same concerns and contained a number of photos.
There's a good debate here about what to show and what to hold back. But there's more to the debate: It's about animals and the emotions that fuel people when it somes to animal stories. News media, at times, show photos of dead people: famines, natural disaster, war, spot news. There's no agreement on when it's right and wrong, but there are times when showing such a photo is right and just and necessary. News media printed photos of Saddam Hussein being hanged. Media didn't have the choice when it came to Osama bin laden's death - the photos were not accessible.
There are no rules, only guidelines and taste. On this one, the story is truly an oddity and context is everything. I'm not looking at someone's big game trophy hunt scrapbook. Police shot a big bear in a densely populated part of the city near schools. Show me the bear.
Photos:
Black bear dead in Burlington. Shot by Halton tactical police officers.
Earlier this month, a young woman and her horse were killed after a collision with a truck. Some readers felt the spot news photo should not have made online or print news.

Recent Comments